The Maine Supreme Judicial Court has upheld a lower court ruling granting a father final authority over whether his daughter may attend a specific evangelical church, concluding that the decision was based on concerns about the child’s well-being rather than on religious beliefs themselves. In a Sept. 1 decision, the state’s highest court affirmed a 2024 ruling involving Matthew Bradeen and Emily Bickford, who disagreed over the religious upbringing of their daughter, then 11 years old. Bickford had regularly taken her daughter to services at Calvary Chapel Greater Portland in Westbrook, while Bradeen argued that the church environment had negatively affected the child’s mental and emotional health.
According to court records, Bradeen testified that his daughter experienced significant anxiety linked to teachings she heard at the church, including messages about the rapture. He reported that the child suffered a panic attack after exposure to those teachings and described the church atmosphere as harmful. The original district court ruling found that certain messages the child received at church were psychologically damaging and contributed to conflict within the family. As a result, the court granted Bradeen authority to decide whether his daughter could continue attending services at Calvary Chapel Greater Portland or interact with church members outside of her mother. While both parents retain shared responsibilities regarding the child’s exposure to religion generally, the father now has final decision-making authority if disagreements arise.
The case drew additional attention because of a church service held while custody proceedings were underway. During that service, Calvary Chapel pastor Travis Carey led a lengthy prayer focused on the family’s legal dispute, repeatedly naming the parents and child. According to court findings, Bradeen was described as “in need of salvation,” and the proceedings were characterized as “an attack on God’s Word.” The Maine Supreme Judicial Court noted that Bickford did not remove her daughter from the service and later defended it as appropriate. The court concluded that she failed to recognize the potential harm such messages could cause, particularly if they alienated the child from her father.
In affirming the lower court’s decision, the justices emphasized that the case was not a judgment on Christianity or biblical beliefs. Instead, they found the daughter had been harmed by exposure to messages portraying her father as an enemy of her faith and by her mother’s unwillingness to mitigate those messages. Judge Jennifer Nofsinger previously wrote that the problem was not a belief system rooted in the Bible but rather the parents’ inability to co-parent effectively on religious matters. The Maine Supreme Judicial Court agreed, stating that the order rested on parental conflict and concerns about the child’s welfare, not on the substance of Bickford’s religious convictions.
Bickford’s attorney, Mat Staver of Liberty Counsel, said he intends to appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court. Liberty Counsel argued that the ruling violated Bickford’s First Amendment rights by restricting her ability to direct her daughter’s religious upbringing and demonstrated hostility toward religious expression. Staver contends the decision conflicts with rulings in other states and could carry significant implications for religious liberty and parental rights. Meanwhile, Michelle King, the attorney representing Bradeen, praised the ruling as carefully reasoned and said her client was pleased with the outcome.
PRAY: Pray that this case will be overturned and that parents will not lose their children just because they want to take them to church and share the Gospel with them.

